PIA vs Surfshark

$6.95
$2.91 Per Month

Best For

  • Privacy
  • Security
  • Android
  • Windows
  • Hide IP
$11.95
$1.99 Per Month

Best For

  • Streaming
  • Privacy
  • Cheap
  • Torrenting
  • China
  • HuluHulu

Securing your digital whereabouts has become much important than protecting your physical footprints.

You might be wondering,

Why did I have to disclose this bitter truth?

Because learning about an appropriate VPN service has become need of an hour for both new and pro privacy seekers.

Look, VPN is not a rocket science.

Even so, it does not mean that it is a piece of cake either.

Therefore, I would suggest you to go through my comprehensive review of PIA vs Surfshark. By doing so, you will realize the actual importance of VPNs appropriately.

PIA vs Surfshark VPN: Head to Head

Surfshark despite being a new entrant in the privacy industry has surpassed PIA comprehensively. What makes the latter different from the former is its jurisdiction feature.

This is because Surfshark belongs to one of the safest countries British Virgin Island. On the other hand, PIA is situated at the US where privacy network providers have to comply with data retention laws.

Major CharacteristicsPrivate Internet AccessSurfshark
Ease of UseYesYes
SpeedAverageAbove average
FeaturesGoodExcellent
Help & SupportGoodExcellent
Value for MoneyYesYes
PrivacyYesYes
Torrenting SupportAllows torrentingAllows torrenting
Money Back Guarantee7 days30 days
Social Media PresenceStrong presenceOnly available on Facebook, Twitter, & Instagram,
Logging PolicyNoNo
Unique Selling PropositionUnlimited Multi-logins
Trustpilot Reviews4756 Reviews40 Reviews

Winner: Based on the above-described attributes, PIA turns out to be a clear winner.

Overview

Private Internet Access is a US based VPN service. Conversely, Surfshark is a British Virgin Island based product. In case you opt the latter, chances are that you will not anticipate data logging problems.

  • Jurisdiction: US
  • Offers 256-bit military grade encryption
  • 3100+ servers in 33+ countries
  • Users can avail multi-login feature
  • 30 days money back guarantee
  • Netflix unblocking: No
  • Jurisdiction: British Virgin Island
  • Delivers 256-bit military grade encryption
  • 500+ servers in 50+ countries
  • 30 days money back guarantee
  • Unlimited multi-login
  • Netflix Unblocking: Yes

Winner: Surfshark is a standout performer in terms of jurisdiction and Netflix unblocking.

Pricing

Surfshark has amazed its potential as well as existing subscribers a great deal. On the other hand, PIA is not too far behind Surfshark.

Surprisingly, both private network providers do not offer three-year pricing plans to their users.

  • One month pricing plan:$ :$6.95 /month
  • Yearly pricing plan:$ 3.33 /month (52% discount)
  • Two yearly pricing plan:$2.91/month (58% discount)
  • One month pricing plan:$11.95%
  • Yearly pricing plan:$5.99 (50% discount)
  • Two yearly pricing plan: $1.99/month (83% discount)

Winner: Based on humongous discount on its two-year pricing deal, I rate Surfshark a winner.

Features

FeaturesPrivate Internet AccessSurfshark
JurisdictionUSBritish Virgin Island
Servers3100+ servers in 33+ countries500+ servers in 50+ countries
Customer SupportYes (live chat feature is unavailable)Yes (live chat is available)
ProtocolsOpenVPN, PPTP and IPSEC/L2TPOpenVPN & IKEv2
Encryption256-bit military grade encryption256-bit military grade encryption
Internet Kill SwitchYesYes
CompatibilityWindows, Mac, Android, iOSWindows, Mac, Android, iOS, Smart TVs
TorrentingSupportedSupported
Logging PolicyNoNo
Money Back Guarantee7 days30 days
Payment OptionsNumerous options including BitcoinNumerous options including Bitcoin

Winner: Due to impressive server network and multiple protocol feature, I have termed PIA a front-runner.

Payment Methods

If your VPN service offers multiple payment methods, you can use your service with complete freedom. Yes, you have read it correctly.

Both Surfshark and Private Internet Access have provided different payment options to their subscribers. Hence, you are free to pay your subscriptions from anywhere without any hassle.

  • PayPal
  • Bitcoin
  • Discover
  • Visa
  • PayPal
  • Bitcoin
  • Discover
  • Visa

Final Verdict: Tied

Servers

Servers’ network availability plays a crucial role in the success of any VPN service. PIA in this regard has done all the hard work. They have catered their user’s privacy requirements with 3100+ servers globally.

Surfshark is a new comer in an online privacy industry. It will take ample time to increase its server network.

Still, keep your fingers crossed to see some drastic improvements in terms of its servers’ presence. At present, you can connect to any server of your choice from 500+ servers worldwide.

  • Offers 3100+ servers in 35+ countries
  • Provides 500+ servers in 50+ countries

Loser: Surfshark is a loser here.

Unique Selling Proposition

Surfshark delivers a next level unlimited multi-login feature to its users. Moreover, the brand allows you to access US Netflix media content from anywhere.

PIA in this case will have to come up with something exceptional and exciting. Sadly, you cannot choose PIA to accomplish your Netflix streaming needs.

  • Unmetered VPN Transfer
  • Multi-login feature applicable on five devices at a time
  • No live chat
  • Netflix Unblocking
  • Unlimited multi-login benefit
  • Live chat

Loser: Unfortunately, PIA has not met its users’ expectations when it comes to unique selling proposition. Hence, I declare them a loser.

Performance and Reliability

I found Surfshark quite handy and trustworthy since you can use the service in China accordingly. Unluckily, you cannot trust PIA as it does not offer required level of security in Chinese territory.

Still, Surfshark has to improve new servers to grab the attention of potential users in future. PIA has performed well in the domain of servers network and protocols too.

However, it does not fulfill security requirements of Chinese netizens.

  • Follows no logging policy but located in the US
  • Does not work in China
  • Based in British Virgin Island and does not log users’ information
  • Works in China

Verdict: Surfshark is a winner.

Compatibility

Both PIA and Surfshark have literally won hearts of their subscribers in terms of compatibility. You are free to download and install these privacy providers on multiple operating systems and devices.

Furthermore, you can install these brands on Smart TVs and routers too.

  • Compatible with Windows, Mac, Android, iOS and Firestick
  • Compatible with Windows, Mac, Android, iOS and Firestick

Winner: There is no clear winner in this situation.

Security and Privacy

PIA has beaten Surfshark by proving its immaculate no-logging feature on number of occasions. Surfshark has to add some benefits to become one of the major enforcers in a digital privacy industry.

Likewise, Private Internet Access is a seasoned campaigner. This is because it has been working in the market for almost a decade. Therefore, PIA has a clear advantage over Surfshark due to seniority.

Loser: Surfshark is a loser but it is not too far behind.

Protocols

Surfshark only offers OpenVPN and IKEv2 protocols to its subscribers. On the other hand, PIA delivers different tunneling protocols that allow you to secure your data hassle-free.

You can avail PPTP, IPsec/L2TP, and OpenVPN protocols after subscribing to PIA.

  • OpenVPN, PPTP, & L2TP/IPsec
  • OpenVPN & IKEv2

Winner: In terms of tunneling protocols, PIA is an obvious winner.

Torrenting / P2P

Both Surfshark and PIA support torrenting needs of their subscribers. However, a catch lies in the form of jurisdiction. PIA is mainly based at the US subsequently not a right option for torrenting.

Surfshark is a feasible solution when it comes to bypassing torrenting hassles.

  • Supports P2P activities
  • Allows torrenting on servers available in major countries
  • Endorses P2P activities
  • Allows torrenting on servers present in major countries

Winner: Surfshark is a winner as it chiefly operates from the British Virgin Islands.

Speed Test

Surfshark has surprised to its users to certain degree. Yes, you have read it accurately. You can enjoy decent streaming speeds while watching your favorite media stuff.

When I used 30mbps connection, I encountered below mentioned findings.

Surfshark-Speed-Test

Therefore, explore a detailed Surfshark VPN review to know hidden gems of the service.

On the contrary, PIA may disappoint you a bit in terms of speeds. Upon using 30mpbs connection, I received following results.

PIA-Speed-Test

Winner: PIA is not a winner based on the above speed test performance.

Logging Policy

PIA has set itself apart from other VPN services by some long distance. Yes, you read it correctly. Recently, the US based service had to prove its innocence against its no logging claims.

It becomes clear that you cannot associate online activities with users’ identities in case they use VPNs.   However, Surfshark is also following the footsteps of PIA and other VPNs that do not log users’ data.

  • Does not log users’ data
  • Does not have logging policy

Winner: PIA has proved its no–logging claims twice. Thus, I declare PIA a winner in this scenario.

Customer Support

Surfshark has added an impressive customer support feature in its armory. Likewise, you can contact its live chat to solve all your queries timely.

PIA also provides an efficient customer assistance to their users. Still, lack of live chat halts its progress to another level.

  • Contact Us
  • Setup guides
  • Does not have live chat feature
  • FAQs
  • Contact Us
  • Help center
  • Offers live chat feature
  • FAQs

Loser: PIA is a loser because of unavailability of live chat benefit.

Netflix Streaming

As I already said, you will have to rely on Surfshark to unblock Netflix US content. Unfortunately, PIA does not offer such kind of luxury to its users at present.

Previously, PIA was able to unblock US Netflix but it cannot do the same for users anymore.

  • Does not unblock Netflix
  • Unblocks Netflix

Loser: Private Internet Access needs some luck to achieve Netflix unblocking objective. In the meantime, Surfshark gives its users an eye-catching Netflix streaming feature.

Refund Policy/ Money Back Guarantee

Surfshark offers a clear advantage in terms of money back guarantee. The newest privacy brand allows its users to claim for the refund within 30 days.

You may search its terms of service section for better understanding.

Surprisingly, you will be astonished to know that PIA only offers 7 days money back guarantee. This is the reason Surfshark becomes an exciting choice for newbies as they can avail money back guarantee.

  • Refund policy is valid within 7 days
  • Users can claim for refunds within 30 days

Check out an exclusive Private Internet Access review to discover unknown benefits of the provider.

Final Verdict:

Surfshark has much improved refund policy procedure as compared to PIA refund policy. Thus, I declare Surfshark a winner.

Ratings

I expect you would be now in a better state to make a wise decision about your privacy. I invested time and efforts to provide a realistic comparison between Surfshark vs PIA.

CategoriesPrivate Internet AccessSurfshark
Pricing8.59.5
Servers9.58
Features1010
Netflix Streaming07
Workable in China08
Apps & Functionality99
Torrenting78
Total Points (70)4459.5

Surfshark VPN vs PIA Review Trustpilot

Trustpilot is one of the most popular customer review sites that offer unbiased review about distinct products and services. Surfshark is far from being perfect product.

However, it has received positive reviews from users mostly.

Surfshark-TrustPilot-Review

If I compare PIA with Surfshark, I was able to found positive reviews from PIA users as well.

TrustPilot-PIA-Review

Winner: PIA is an obvious victor as it has more than 4500+ reviews on Trustpilot. Besides, numerous users have raised their voices in favor of Private Internet Access.

Private Internet Access vs Surfshark Reddit Review

Reddit being a famous interactive platform offers clear insights about numerous VPNs and other services. Users have given mixed reviews about PIA on Reddit.

The brand primarily operates from the US. This is the reason one subscriber stopped using the service.

Likewise, Surfshark has also received some encouraging comments from users.

Winner: PIA has attained more positive feedback than Surfshark. For that reason, I have rated PIA as a winner.

Check out our Other Comparisons

Final Verdict

It does not matter where you live. You have to secure your digital identity from ISPs, hackers, and other dangerous factors. VPNs have truly become last resort for privacy seekers.

It is high time for you to use a VPN after studying my comprehensive review of PIA vs Surfshark.

I have mentioned all the salient attributes of both Surfshark and Private Internet Access in detail.

If you want to know my verdict about the winner, I would go with PIA.

In case you are wondering, why I have chosen PIA over Surfshark?

It is quite simple.

The former has won my vote because of its unmatched logging policy advantage.

Now, select a VPN like Surfshark or PIA and start protecting all your confidential information in no time.

Tell me in the comments section below which VPN you liked the most and why.

Usman Hayat

Usman Hayat

Author
Posts by Usman Hayat

Usman Hayat's Biography :


A business school grad specializing in marketing, Usman found his love for writing during studies. Salmi now pursues a career as a digital privacy & security advocate for VPNRanks working as a blogger. Salmi loves reading about sci-fi & technology while cricket is his game of choice. When the world cries ‘online freedom’ Salmi stands resolute raising his voice for the rights of netizens everywhere.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *