NordVPN VS PIA – Which is the Best one In Italy (2023)?

  • Last updated May 3, 2024
  • written by
    Editor

Both VPNs offer almost similar features.

PIA has a large server network with over 35500 servers, while NordVPN offers 6000 servers only. PIA is cheaper and offers features like split tunneling and port forwarding in Italy. However, NordVPN can unblock more streaming services and is also 3.53 Mbps faster as compared to PIA VPN.

Overall, when comparing NordVPN and PIA to see which one offers better privacy, security, and online accessibility, we found NordVPN to be the Winner in Italy.

In this head-to-head comparison, you’ll be able to find comparative tables to help you decide on choosing NordVPN or PIA in Italy?

Here are some factors we used to compare NordVPN vs PIA In Italy:

  • Features – Which provider offers better security features in Italy?
  • Multi Logins – Which provider offers more multi-logins in Italy?
  • Speed – Which one is faster in Italy?
  • Logging Policies – Which one keeps fewer logs in Italy?
  • Jurisdiction – Which provider is headquartered in a safer jurisdiction?
  • Unblocking Capabilities – Which VPN is better at unblocking streaming services in Italy?
  • Price – Which VPN is cheaper in Italy?
  • Refund Policy – Which provider offers a better refund policy in Italy?

NordVPN unquestionably wins this comparison in Italy because it has a massive server network and top-notch features. Here’s a rundown of some of the most prominent features of NordVPN that give it an edge over PIA:

NordVPN is the winner in Italy!

  • Logging: NordVPN does not keep any logs in Italy
  • Speed: 24.91 Mbps
  • Jurisdiction: Panama (safe for a VPN service)
  • Support: Live Chat, Faqs, guides, email
  • Streaming: Netflix, BBC iPlayer, Hulu, Amazon Prime, etc

A Quick Comparison of NordVPN and PIA In Italy

If you don’t want to read in detail then you can check the list of factors we have used to compare NordVPN and PIA in the below table. Also, you can explore our detailed VPN comparison chart.

Factors NordVPN PIA VPN
Jurisdiction Panama USA
Logging Policy No logs No logs
Best value for your money EUR3.68/mo (US$ 3.99/mo) - Save up to 63% with exclusive 2-year plan + 3 months free EUR1.95/mo (US$ 2.11/mo)
Speed 24.91 Mbps 21.4 Mbps
Server Network 5500+ servers 59 countries 24305+ servers 77 countries
Customer Support Live chat, Email, Faq, Guides Live chat, Email, Faq, Guides
Torrenting Supported Supported
Netflix Unblocking Supported Inconsistent
Security Powerful Powerful
Review NordVPN review in Italy PIA VPN review in Italy
Website nordvpn.com privateinternetaccess.com

Detailed Comparison of NordVPN and PIA In Italy

NordVPN and PIA are undoubtedly two big names in the industry in Italy. Both VPNs have been in the market for decades now. On the surface, both VPNs tend to offer similar features. For instance, both VPNs offer a Kill switch, DNS leak protection, malware protection, and no logs policy.

However, NordVPN has an edge over PIA VPN because of its safe Panama jurisdiction. In addition, its extra value-added features such as double encryption and TOR over VPN allow NordVPN to even work in heavingly censored countries (China) where PIA doesn’t.

1. Pricing Plans

Result: PIA is slightly cheaper than NordVPN by costing $1.02 less in Italy.

Plans PIA VPN NordVPN
1-month $11.95/mo $11.95/mo
1-year $3.33/mo $4.92/mo
2-year $2.69/mo $4.13/mo

NordVPN – It offers three subscription plans which include a 2-year plan, a 1-year plan, and a 1-month plan. Its most affordable plan costs EUR3.68/mo (US$ 3.99/mo) - Save up to 63% with exclusive 2-year plan + 3 months free, however, PIA VPN’s plans are still cheaper than NordVPN in Italy.

PIA – The subscription plans of PIA include monthly, yearly, and 2-year plans. Although the pricing for each plan is listed in the table above, it’s worth noting that PIA VPN is quite cheaper than NordVPN. PIA wins this round in Italy.

View our detailed VPN comparison chart in Italy to check out other budget-friendly VPNs.

Payment Methods and Refund Policy

Result: Although both providers offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, PIA offers more payment methods than NordVPN in Italy.

Payment method & Refund NordVPN PIA VPN
Credit Card Yes Yes
PayPal No Yes
Cryptocurrency Yes Yes
Mint No Yes
Amazon Pay No Yes
30-day Money-back guarantee Yes Yes

NordVPN – It can be purchased through either credit cards or cryptocurrencies. That’s about it. Similar to PIA VPN, NordVPN subscription packages are refundable within 30 days in Italy.

PIA VPN – It offers a 30-day refund policy but also accepts way more payment options than NordVPN. Instead of just accepting credit cards and crypto, PIA VPN also accepts payments made through PayPal, Amazon Pay, and Mint.

The provider you decide to go with must have a clear refund policy. There are providers such as TunnelBear, that offer refunds on a case-by-case basis and you wouldn’t want to be stuck with them regarding your funds. Your refund request may get disapproved by TunnelBear if you decide to not continue with the subscription. Therefore, always make sure to check the refund policy yourself before committing to any VPN provider.

Although the TunnelBear refund policy may seem dodgy, it is still one of the best VPN providers in the industry in Italyand can go toe-to-toe with top-tier VPN providers. Recently, we compared it with NordVPN, see how it performs in NordVPN and TunnelBear comparison.

2. Jurisdiction: NordVPN vs PIA

Result: NordVPN is headquartered in the safe jurisdiction of Panama, whereas PIA is not (USA).

NordVPN PIA VPN
Panama
(Safe)
United States
(Unsafe)

NordVPN – It is headquartered in the safe jurisdiction of Panama. This country is considered a heaven for online privacy. With no mandatory data retention laws in place, ISPs in Panama are not obligated to keep logs.

PIA – It is located in the unsafe jurisdiction of the United States. This is one of the major downsides of Private Internet Access. Being headquartered in the US, law enforcement agencies can legally ask PIA VPN to hand over user data.

Jurisdiction is very important when you are deciding on a VPN for yourself. You don’t want to rely on a VPN provider like Private Internet Access, which is operating from the US, and risk your online privacy and data. Speaking of PIA, even though it is a competitive VPN provider on many levels with ExpressVPN, due to its jurisdiction, it is not a favorite. Check out how it performs against top-tier VPN in ExpressVPN vs PIA

3. Logging Policy

Result: NordVPN has a clearer and proven no-logging policy, whereas PIA’s logging policy is quite vague.

NordVPN PIA VPN
No logs retained No traffic logs, but the overall policy is vague

NordVPN – It comes with a great logging policy that guarantees no storage of user data at all in Italy. With no timestamps, IP addresses, and bandwidth logs, there is no way that any authority can compromise your privacy. Best of all, it is headquartered in the data retention-free jurisdiction of Panama.

PIA VPN – It doesn’t reveal what kind of information they keep on their privacy policy page. However, it has never been caught involved in any scandals related to revealing user information. While PIA keeps no logs, it is stated in its privacy policy that the provision of personal information is partly required by law.

Despite its privacy policy, the USA is not a good jurisdiction for a VPN to be headquartered in. This was also the case in NordVPN and TorGuard review in Italy, as TorGuard is also based in the USA, which is a leading member of the 5-Eyes alliance.

4. Speed: NordVPN vs Private Internet Access

Result: NordVPN is faster by 3.53 Mbps on average than PIA VPN in Italy.

Speed is another key performance factor to determine the better service between these two. Because let’s face it, if a VPN is not fast, you can’t download torrents with it or browse your favorite shows on Netflix in Italy.

Speed in Countries NordVPN PIA VPN
US 25.46 Mbps 19.16 Mbps
UK 25.09 Mbps 25.78 Mbps
Germany 24.29 Mbps 22.25 Mbps
Australia 24.81 Mbps 18.4 Mbps
Avg. Download 24.91 Mbps 21.39 Mbps

NordVPN – Testing the service on a 30 Mbps connection, NordVPN didn’t disappoint delivering remarkably good speeds at 24.91 Mbps on average the same case is also seen in the NordVPN and VyprVPN comparison in Italy. Check out NordVPN speed test results in Italy for more clarity.

PIA – It couldn’t deliver the same level of speed as NordVPN, however, it still managed to achieve an average speed of 21.39 Mbps which is not too far behind NordVPN. Therefore, NordVPN once again is the winner in Italy.

5. Server Network: PIA vs. NordVPN

Result: PIA has roughly 18,150 more servers than NordVPN.

NordVPN PIA VPN
5500+ servers in 59 countries

24305+ servers in 77 countries

NordVPN – It offers significantly fewer servers as compared to PIA. The server network of this provider encompasses more than 5500+ servers with a presence in 59 countries. But the good thing about NordVPN is that all of its servers are physical and not virtual.

PIA VPN – It offers a decent server network consisting of 24,305+ VPN servers in 77 countries. PIA VPN also uses entirely bare-metal (physical) servers.

6. Compatibility: NordVPN vs Private Internet Access In Italy

Result: Both PIA and NordVPN support a wide range of operating systems and devices.

Compatibility NordVPN PIA VPN
Android Yes Yes
iOS Yes Yes
Windows Yes Yes
macOS Yes Yes
Linux Yes Yes
Opera Yes No
Chrome Yes Yes
Firefox Yes Yes
Router Yes Yes

On the compatibility front, both NordVPN and PIA support similar platforms/devices. As such, both of these providers are evenly contested when it comes to compatibility in Italy.

NordVPN It supports a wide range of devices, including Android TV, Firefox, Chrome, Windows, macOS in Italy, iOS, Android, and more. NordVPN is also compatible with routers, which in turn makes it compatible with devices that don’t support VPNs natively.

PIA VPN – It is compatible with desktops and smartphones, including PC, Mac, Linux, iOS, and Android. However, unlike NordVPN, PIA VPN also supports the Opera browser which is a big plus. But all in all, both providers more or less support the same kind of devices.

7. Customer Support: PIA vs NordVPN

Result: NordVPN offers live chat support with a response time of 30 seconds in Italy

Support NordVPN PIA VPN
Live chat Yes Yes (requires a lot of steps)
Email support Yes Yes
News No Yes
Troubleshooting guides Yes Yes
Setup guides Yes Yes
FAQs Yes No

NordVPN In this comparison, we found that NordVPN is better than PIA in terms of customer support. We were pleasantly surprised to see that it only took 30 seconds for NordVPN to entertain our query.

NordVPN-customer-support-in-Italy

PIA – The customer support is notably inferior compared to NordVPN. When it comes to providing easy live chat functionality, PIA VPN is not all that good. The reason is that you’ll need to fill in a short form just to get in contact with their live chat representative in Italy. NordVPN wins this round for its excellent and responsive live chat support.

8. Torrenting: Private Internet Access vs NordVPN

Result: NordVPNin Italy offers better torrenting than PIA, thanks to its obfuscation technology and thousands of servers.

Torrenting Features NordVPN PIA VPN
No Logs Yes Yes
Fast Speeds Yes Yes
Unlimited Bandwidth Yes Yes
Obfuscation Yes No
Safe Jurisdiction Yes No
Leak-Proof Yes Yes

NordVPN It offers a wide range of P2P-enabled servers that can help you access and download any torrent file you can imagine in Italy. In addition, thanks to its obfuscation technology, NordVPN can stay under the radar of your ISP. The system-wide kill switch feature of NordVPN ensures that your IP doesn’t leak while you are torrenting in Italy. It also offers high download speeds for torrenting as can be seen in the comparison between NordVPN and PureVPN in Italy.

PIA VPN It supports P2P networking and torrenting on its servers. In fact, it has a port-forwarding feature specially designed to optimize your torrenting speed. However, the fact that PIA is located in the US means that the company will have to comply with any DMCA notices it receives.

NordVPN is headquartered in Panama, it is significantly safer than PIA.

9. Unblocking Strength: PIA VPN vs NordVPN

Result: NordVPN can unblock more streaming services than PIA VPN in Italy.

Unblocking streaming channels are one of the major reasons for using VPNs in Italy. To can find out which VPN can unblock more streaming services in Italy with the help of this table.

Streaming Channels NordVPN PIA VPN
Netflix Yes Yes
HBO GO Yes Yes
Disney Plus Yes No
Hulu Yes Yes
Amazon Prime Video Yes Yes
Sling TV Yes No
Fubo TV Yes No
BBC iPlayer Yes Yes

NordVPN It can effortlessly unblock Netflix along with a bunch of other streaming services in Italy as mentioned in the table above. As for performance, in our testing, NordVPN managed to deliver HD streaming quality. So, it is proved that NordVPN Netflix in Italy and streaming of other platforms are the perfect combinations.

PIA It didn’t perform too well in the streaming category. It didn’t manage to unblock Disney Plus, Sling TV, and Fubo TV. It did manage to unblock US Netflix, however, not consistently. This can also be seen in the IPVanish vs PIA in Italy and PIA VPN vs PureVPN in Italy comparison where PIA only managed to unblock Netflix US and it also took us quite some time to find the US server that works with Netflix.

10. Security and Features

Result: NordVPN offers more security features in Italy, however, PIA is not too far behind.

Although both VPNs offer similar features and have strong security you can find out which one offers more value for money.

Security Features NordVPN PIA VPN
AES-256 encryption Yes Yes
Leak protection Yes Yes
Kill switch Yes Yes
Multi-logins 10 10
Benchmark protocols Yes Yes
Onion over VPN Yes No
Double VPN Yes No
Obfuscation Yes No
Ad/malware blocker Yes Yes
Split tunneling Yes Yes
SOCKS5 proxy Yes No

NordVPN – It offers significantly more features than the PIA VPN. Both providers have the following features in common:

  • AES-256 encryption
  • OpenVPN tunneling protocols
  • IP/DNS leak protection
  • Ads, tracker, and malware blocker
  • P2P support
  • Browser extension
  • Killswitch

But NordVPN has multiple unique features that PIA doesn’t have:

  • Onion over VPN – Combination of Tor + VPN in Italy technology for users that need greater security
  • DoubleVPN – The VPN chaining technology that increases user security by routing data through 2 servers
  • Dedicated IP addresses
  • 6 simultaneous connections

On the other hand, PIA has only these unique features:

  • SOCKS5
  • 10 simultaneous connections

Aside from NordVPN and PIA VPN, PureVPN and IPVanish also offer pretty cool security features. Just to get an idea, check out our PureVPN vs IPVanish comparison in Italy.

11. NordVPN VS PIA 2023 Reddit

Result: NordVPN is recommended by more Reddit users than PIA VPN in Italy.

If you head over to Reddit, you’ll see most people recommending NordVPN over Private Internet Access. Here’s one comment mentioning that NordVPN is much easier to use out of the box than PIA:

Reddit-comment-1

Here’s another comment stating that PIA is not what it used to be:

Reddit-comment-2

So, judging by most Reddit comments, NordVPN wins this round.

Other NordVPN Comparisons

Final Verdict – PIA vs NordVPN In Italy

So based on our detailed NordVPN vs PIA comparison in Italy, NordVPN is the winner. PIA is still a very powerful contender with a large server network and features like port forwarding, and SOCKS5 proxy. NordVPN managed to perform better in major areas such as streaming, jurisdiction, logging policy, and more.

Nonetheless, PIA is still a very reliable and reputable VPN in Italy. However, the fact that it is headquartered in the US and lacks in some key performance areas, makes NordVPN the winner in our head-to-head comparison.

MoreComparisons


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *