Reading Time: 9 minutes

Comcast is one of the largest internet service providers operating in 40 US states as well as the District of Columbia. It has fought aggressively to repeal net neutrality laws. Despite that, it is known to throttle and log the data of its customers.

Xfinity actively tracks its customers’ online activities and literally sells collected data to third-party advertisers. If you’re stuck with Comcast, the best way out for you is either to try and cancel your subscription or opt for the best VPN for Comcast Xfinity.

Since Comcast will likely not let you go, we’ve come up with a list of the 5 best VPNs for Xfinity that can help you bypass ISP throttling and secure your online data. Before we get started, we highly recommend getting ExpressVPN for Xfinity. 

5 Best VPNs for Comcast Xfinity in 2022 – Quick Overview

Here is a list of the best VPN for Comcast Xfinity in 2022:

  1. ExpressVPN – The best VPN for Comcast Xfinity.
  2. Surfshark – Budget-friendly VPN for Xfinity users.
  3. NordVPN – Secure VPN with a strictly tested no-logging policy.
  4. CyberGhost – User-friendly VPN for Comcast Xfinity.
  5. PIA –  Reliable privacy-oriented Comcast VPN.

Detailed Analysis | FAQs

Get ExpressVPN for Xfinity30 Days Money Back Guarantee

5 Best VPNs for Comcast Xfinity [In-Depth Analysis]

To make it super easy for you, we tested 50+ VPNs and compiled a list of 5 powerful VPN services below that are not only affordable but also super-secure. Among all VPNs, ExpressVPN remains our top choice as an Xfinity router VPN:

1. ExpressVPNThe Best VPN for Comcast Xfinity

  • 3000+ servers in 94 countries (25 server locations in the US)
  • AES 256-bit encryption
  • Strict no-logging policy
  • Kill switch
  • DNS leak protection
  • All servers are P2P-optimized
  • 5 simultaneous connections
  • Compatible operating systems for Android, Windows, Mac, iOS, Linux, and FireOS
  • 30-day money-back guarantee

ExpressVPN is the best VPN for Comcast Xfinity modem, all thanks to its powerful security features, fast speeds, and robust unblocking capabilities. You can use this powerful VPN to evade Comcast’s throttling tactics.

This VPN provider is based in the British Virgin Islands, which is actually a country free from all kinds of data retention laws. Therefore, the VPN offers a strict no-logs policy, ensuring that no data of Comcast Xfinity users is collected by this virtual private network.

Its security features include zero-knowledge DNS, kill switch, split tunneling, and the industry’s best leak protection. All these features combine and ensure that your internet activity is completely private.

expressvpn-kill-switch

It disconnects you from the internet if your VPN connection drops.

It further offers complete encryption with protocols like OpenVPN and Lightway. These encryptions cannot be cracked at all unless you have some super tactics. Even with cyberattacks, cybercriminals will only be able to retrieve data for a very short period of time.

This VPN also offers 3000+ servers worldwide for HD streaming. It can easily unblock almost all popular geo-restricted streaming services, including Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime, CraveTV, BBC iPlayer, and more. It’s P2P-friendly as well.

As for ExpressVPN’s speeds, it is really fast. We conducted an ExpressVPN speed test on its USA – New York server and got an average downloading speed of 87.78 Mbps and an uploading speed of 42.22 Mbps on a 100 Mbps connection.

expressvpn speed

We tested its USA – New York server, and the results were great.

You can set ExpressVPN on your FireStick, Android, iOS, Roku, Windows, Mac, Smart TVs, and more pretty easily using its dedicated app for devices.

If you’re thinking, is this VPN compatible with Xfinity? Then, well, yes, it is! You can get ExpressVPN on your Xfinity and other routers without any hassle.

This all-rounder VPN comes only at an affordable price of $6.67/mo (Save 49% and get 3 extra months FREE with 12-month plan). It also offers a 30-day money-back guarantee to Comcast Xfinity users wanting to test out its service.

If you want to know more about this VPN service, just read our ExpressVPN review.

Pros
  • Tested as the best VPN for Comcast Xfinity
  • All servers are P2P optimized
  • Lightway protocol makes it highly fast and secure
  • No-logging policy
  • Robust kill switch
  • Thousands of servers in 94 countries
Cons
  • Features are not customizable
  • Doesn’t offer a free plan
Get ExpressVPN for Xfinity30 Days Money Back Guarantee

2. SurfsharkBudget-friendly VPN for Xfinity Users

  • 3200+ servers in 95 countries (600+ servers in 25 US cities)
  • AES 256-bit encryption
  • Strict no-logging policy
  • Kill switch
  • DNS leak protection
  • All servers are P2P-optimized
  • Unlimited simultaneous connections
  • Compatible operating systems for Windows, iOS, Mac, Android, Linux, and FireOS
  • 30-day money-back guarantee

Surfshark is one of the most affordable VPN services for Comcast Xfinity. Despite offering so many features, Surfshark only costs $2.30/mo (Save 81% on 2 Years + 2 Months Free Plan with Surfshark Antivirus). More impressively, every Surfshark plan is covered by a full 30-day money-back guarantee.

Right from the start, there’s a lot to love about Surfshark. If we talk about security, then Surfshark operates from the British Virgin Islands, which is known to have no data retention laws.

Similar to ExpressVPN, Surfshark offers powerful security features and follows a straightforward zero logs policy. It also offers MultiHop, CleanWeb, Whitelister, AES 256-bit encryption, and more.

surfshark-multihop

This feature would encrypt your traffic multiple times, keeping you absolutely secure.

This provider offers 3200+ servers all over the world. Speaking of which, all its servers are optimized to offer blazing fast speeds, which is perfect for streaming on any VPN connection. 

We could access various geo-restricted content and streaming services, including Hulu, Comedy Central, Disney+, Amazon Prime, Showtime, and HBO Max using Surfshark. Not only that, but its servers are great for torrenting as well.

As for speeds, Surfshark may offer fast connections, but they still wouldn’t be able to beat ExpressVPN’s speeds. In our Surfshark speed test conducted on the USA – Atlanta server, it delivered an average downloading speed of 81.32 Mbps and an uploading speed of 76.12 Mbps on a 100 Mbps connection.

surfshark-speed-test

The speed drop wasn’t significant at all while using Surfshark on Xfinity.

It also offers unlimited simultaneous connections for Comcast Xfinity subscribers. This means that if you want a VPN that can be used on as many devices as you like and also offers powerful features, then you should consider Surfshark.

If you want to know more about this VPN service, just read our Surfshark review.

Pros
  • Unlimited simultaneous connections
  • Quite affordable
  • Entire server network is P2P-optimized
  • Whitelister, CleanWeb, and MultiHop
Cons
  • A few servers may be subject to traffic overload
Get Surfshark for Xfinity30 Days Money Back Guarantee

3. NordVPN – Secure VPN with a Strictly Tested No-Logging Policy

  • 5200+ servers in 60 countries (1970+ servers in 15 US cities)
  • AES 256-bit encryption
  • Strict no-logging policy
  • Kill switch
  • DNS leak protection
  • Specific P2P-specialty servers
  • 6 simultaneous connections
  • Compatible operating systems for Linux, Mac, iOS, Windows, Android, and FireOS
  • 30-day money-back guarantee

NordVPN is the most secure Comcast VPN offering a rigorously tested no-logging policy. This logging policy has been independently audited several times and has always lived up to the expectations.

If we talk about one of the best VPN services in the industry, the list wouldn’t be complete without NordVPN. Headquartered in Panama, NordVPN offers 5200+ servers available in 60 countries. A lot of these servers support powerful obfuscation technology.

nordvpn-security-features

You just need to turn the toggle on for activating any feature.

If you don’t know, obfuscated servers can help you bypass geo-restrictions in countries like China, as it hides the fact that you’re using a VPN from your ISP as well.

Not only that, but NordVPN also offers CyberSec, kill switch, DDoS protection, and powerful unblocking features to help you access Netflix and other VoD services without experiencing any throttling.

The VPN is perfectly capable of unblocking multiple streaming services. These include various regional libraries of Netflix, FXNOW, HBO Max, CraveTV, Peacock TV, BBC iPlayer, and more. Furthermore, it offers dedicated P2P servers in the specialty servers section, in case you’re one torrent fan.

While offering great security, NordVPN is also known for its speeds. As per our NordVPN speed test conducted on its USA – Dallas server, the VPN delivered great speeds. On our 100 Mbps connection, we received an average downloading speed of 83.82 Mbps and an uploading speed of 44.64 Mbps.

nordvpn-speed-test

We used NordVPN on Xfinity router, and the speeds were fast.

Despite all the awesome features that are offered by NordVPN, it’s available at a price of $3.99/mo (Save 70% on 2 Years Plan + Extra Subscription). Last but not least, NordVPN is also covered by a full 30-day refund policy.

Want to know more about this VPN service? Just read our detailed NordVPN review.

Pros
  • Most secure VPN as per our testing
  • Over 5000 servers
  • Special torrenting servers
  • Audited no-logging policy
  • Kill switch that’s customizable
Cons
  • Some servers offer slow speeds
  • Doesn’t come with a free version
Get NordVPN for Xfinity30 Days Money Back Guarantee

4. CyberGhost – User-friendly VPN for Comcast Xfinity

  • 7700+ servers in 90 countries (1317 servers in 11 US cities)
  • AES 256-bit encryption
  • Strict no-logging policy
  • Kill switch
  • DNS leak protection
  • Specific P2P-specialty servers
  • 7 simultaneous connections
  • Compatible operating systems for Mac, iOS, Android, FireOS, and Windows
  • 45-day money-back guarantee

CyberGhost is one of the most easy-to-use VPNs for Comcast users. It’s packed with thousands of servers, easy configuration, and dedicated modes for activities like streaming, torrenting, and gaming.

This virtual private network offers rock-solid features to help you evade ISP surveillance. It comes with a strict no-logging policy and military-grade AES 256-bit encryption.

It also offers multiple encryption protocols (including WireGuard), split tunneling, kill switch, and DNS leak protection that help in keeping your activities private from the prying eyes of Comcast.

cyberghost-automatic-kill-switch

You can also find other CyberGhost features like split tunneling in Settings.

The VPN offers optimized servers according to multiple activities. For example, to change Netflix region and unblock the streaming service, you can just visit the ‘for Streaming’ tab present on the CyberGhost app and search for a Netflix-optimized server. The VPN further offers strong unblocking capabilities for Amazon Prime and BBC iPlayer.

cyberghost-optimized-servers-for-streaming

We found multiple dedicated servers for streaming Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon Prime.

CyberGhost is quite speedy as well. For our CyberGhost speed test, we connected to its USA – Chicago server and received an average downloading speed of 75.47 Mbps and an uploading speed of 69.34 Mbps on a 100 Mbps connection.

cyberghost-speed-test

There was a significant speed drop when using CyberGhost.

Best of all, CyberGhost is comes at a price of $2.23/mo . If the price is not enough to convince you, CyberGhost also offers an extensive 45-day money-back guarantee.

In case you find your VPN not working, then you can always try these quick troubleshooting hacks for CyberGhost and make your connection successful again.

To know more about this VPN service, you can simply read our CyberGhost review.

Pros
  • User-friendly and quite cheap
  • Over 7000 servers
  • Dedicated modes for several online activities
  • WireGuard protocol
  • 45-day money-back guarantee
Cons
  • Server speeds are slower than other VPNs
  • Might take time to connect to servers
Get CyberGhost for Xfinity45 Days Money Back Guarantee

5. PIA – Reliable Privacy-Oriented Comcast VPN

  • 35000+ servers in 80 countries (Servers in 18 US locations)
  • AES 256-bit encryption
  • Strict no-logging policy
  • Kill switch
  • DNS leak protection
  • All servers re P2P optimized
  • 10 simultaneous connections
  • Compatible operating systems for Mac, iOS, Android, FireOS, and Windows
  • 30-day money-back guarantee

PIA is a reliable and privacy-focused VPN for Comcast Xfinity. This VPN is quite safe to use, doesn’t collect any user logs, and is preferred by multiple VPN users.

PIA offers 35000+ servers in 80 countries to help you tackle Comcast’s infamous bandwidth throttling tactics.

Not only that, but PIA also offers 256-bit encryption, public Wi-Fi security, kill switch, DNS leak protection, and tons of other amazing features to defeat ISP throttling. It also equips a feature called MACE that blocks all malicious traffic and unwanted ads while browsing.

pia-kill-switch

Navigating through its app is slightly difficult, but you get used to it.

PIA is quite famous for torrenting as it offers P2P servers, L2TP and PPTP protocols, and advanced features such as port forwarding and SOCKS5 support.

It also unblocks all popular geo-restricted streaming services with its extensive server network. These include Netflix, Disney+, Hulu, CraveTV, Hotstar, BBC iPlayer, SlingTV, and more.

However, please note that the speeds of this VPN aren’t as fast as all the VPNs above. But we can’t say that they’re bad at all. In our PIA speed test conducted on its USA – Miami server, we received a reliable average downloading speed of 65.78 Mbps and an uploading speed of 57.16 Mbps on a 100 Mbps connection.

pia-los-angeles-speed-test

Its US – Miami server offers decent speeds for torrenting and streaming.

PIA is covered by a full 30-day money-back guarantee and only costs $2.19/mo . It’s a reliable option in our best VPN for Comcast Xfinity list that offers a decent service to keep you secure on Xfinity.

To learn more about this VPN service, read our PIA review.

Pros
  • Reliable in terms of speeds and privacy
  • Keeps you anonymous over the internet
  • Offers 35500+ servers
  • Advanced features like SOCKS5 and port forwarding
Cons
  • Recorded speeds are slower than other VPNs
  • Frequent disconnection
Get PIA for Xfinity30 Days Money Back Guarantee

Top Reasons to Use a VPN for Comcast

There are a ton of reasons why people avoid Comcast. A few of them are speeds and traffic throttling, but they’re not all. Here are the top 3 reasons why you should use a VPN for Comcast’s Xfinity:

1. Leaked router information

comcast-leaking-router-information

If you don’t know, back in 2018, Xfinity’s router activation site managed to leak the router information of its customers. According to security experts Ryan Stevenson and Karan Saini, Xfinity’s activation website managed to transmit the user’s SSID and password in plain text.

This made it obnoxiously easy for hackers to obtain a victim’s router’s SSID and password with little to no effort. With such valuable information, malicious entities were able to gain unauthorized access and monitor data packets of unencrypted network traffic.

2. Blocked websites

blocked-websites-comcast-xfinity

Again in 2018, a ton of Comcast’s Xfinity customers reported not being able to access websites like Steam, PayPal, and TorrentFreak. There have even been reports of Comcast blocking VPNs and Comcast dropping VPN connections.

Turns out, Comcast’s “protected browsing” setting designed to block access to websites with malware, spyware, and phishing, was also blocking access to perfectly harmless sites. Again, another major blunder that is still prevalent today.

3. Unjustified data harvesting

comcast-data-harvesting

As we mentioned earlier, Comcast is anti-net neutrality. The major corporation has been fighting extensively to repeal net neutrality laws placed by the Obama administration.

Ever since FCC Chairman Ajit Pai repealed two major consumer protection laws, namely broadband privacy and net neutrality, back in 2017, Comcast and other ISP providers can legally throttle bandwidths and browse harvested user data.

These are quite valid reasons for using a VPN on Comcast. Virtual private networks allow you to stay anonymous over the internet, so your data cannot be accessed or stored. They also let you access geo-restricted websites, so accessing sites that Comcast blocks for its users become quite easy.

However, we suggest you always opt for the best VPN for Comcast Xfinity. While our list mentions quite a few, we suggest you try out ExpressVPN.

Get ExpressVPN for Xfinity30 Days Money Back Guarantee

How to Choose the Best VPN for Comcast?

Since Comcast is infamous for throttling bandwidths, you should only choose a VPN that can truly hide your online activities. Here’s what you should look for when choosing the best VPN for Comcast Xfinity:

  • Fast speeds and unlimited bandwidth so you don’t have to worry about running out of data.
  • Excellent compatibility with a variety of devices and should also support simultaneous connections so you can use it on multiple devices at the same time.
  • Encryption & protocols to keep you safe and anonymous online. It should also offer leak protection because Comcast has a history of leaking the personal information of its users.
  • A large number of servers should be offered, especially in the US, as Xfinity is restricted to the States.
  • 24/7 live chat support should be available in case a user has a query or faces some technical issue.
Get ExpressVPN for Xfinity30 Days Money Back Guarantee

Comcast and Xfinity – What are They?

In general, Comcast is the parent organization, while Xfinity is its brand for multiple services like TV cable, internet connection, and telephone services.

While it seems that one got acquired by the other, the news is completely false. Comcast decided to form Xfinity in 2010, offering subscription bundles at discounted prices.


How Can I Use a VPN With Xfinity?

For Comcast VPN Setup, just follow the steps below:

  1. Subscribe to a VPN that best fits your needs (ExpressVPN is the best VPN for Comcast Xfinity).
  2. Then, download the VPN app onto your device.
  3. Log into the VPN using your credentials.
  4. Connect to a VPN server that offers the fastest speeds.
  5. Finally, freely use Xfinity without any restrictions on your internet traffic.
Get ExpressVPN for Xfinity30 Days Money Back Guarantee

How to Set Up a VPN on Xfinity Routers?

Setting up a VPN on the Comcast router is ideal because it lets you protect all devices on the network. It is best if you want to use a VPN on devices that don’t have native support for a VPN, like Smart TVs, gaming consoles, streaming sticks, and more.

However, not all routers are compatible with VPNs because their firmware does not support VPNs. Some of these models include xFi Gateway, Netgear, Linksys, and Motorolla. Fortunately, to set up a VPN on your router, you can replace its firmware. But, be very vigilant because otherwise, you might end up damaging the router.

You can use one of the following firmware to use a VPN on your router:

  • DD-WRT
  • AsusWRT
  • TomatoUSB
  • OpenWRT

Setting up a VPN on your router is not that easy. If you don’t know the answer to: “is my VPN compatible with Xfinity?” or don’t want to go through the hassle of Xfinity VPN setup, then you can also get ExpressVPN’s pre-flashed routers to get started immediately.


Comcast Bandwidth Throttling: Then and Now

Comcast’s first data throttling case came into the limelight in 2006. The organization installed a hardware named Sandvine that disrupted the protocols used by P2P clients, such as BitTorrent. This started preventing users from uploading files.

This policy wasn’t revealed to the customers for a long time. Finally, in 2008,  an FFC investigation demanded that Comcast end these discriminative approaches. 

Even though the organization complied with the demand, it appealed in court. While this continued, the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled out that the FCC doesn’t have the jurisdiction to issue directives. After this, late in 2008, Comcast was discovered to have throttled VoIP apps, such as Facetime and Skype.

In late 2013, Verizon and Comcast were found to be throttling Netflix streams, which was resulting in poor video playback quality and prolonged buffering times. Both the organizations accused Netflix of taking advantage of them, while Netflix declared that it was being discriminated against.

Finally, in 2014, Netflix and Comcast had an agreement where Netflix would pay Comcast to end bandwidth throttling. However, again in 2018, Comcast’s tactics were found to disrupt the internet of consumers. And it’s bound to continue.


Comcast Geo-restrictions

Comcast is one of the largest internet service providers operating in 40 US states as well as the District of Columbia. Yet despite its massive stature and user base of around 30.3 million, it is one of the most hated companies in the U.S.

comcast-customer-graph

Ranging from horrible customer service to an absurd pricing system, there’s a reason why people hate Comcast so much. But nothing even comes close to their horrible bandwidth throttling tactics. If you’re a Comcast user, you know how frustrating it can get.

bandwidth-throttling-comcast-xfinityNetflix even accused Comcast of deliberately throttling its streaming bandwidth in order to maintain its virtual monopoly. [Source]

Even worse? Since Comcast has fought aggressively to repeal net neutrality laws, Xfinity actively tracks its customers’ online activities and literally sells collected data to third-party advertisers.

If you’re stuck with Comcast, the best way out for you is either to try and cancel your subscription or opt for the best VPN for Comcast Xfinity.

Get ExpressVPN for Xfinity30 Days Money Back Guarantee

Does Xfinity Support VPN?

Yes, Xfinity actually supports VPNs. In fact, they have a separate blog post about it on their website. As long as you’re using a VPN for personal use and not for commercial use, you’re not going to violate Xfinity’s terms of service.

If you’re using your personal WiFi router connected with Xfinity on your internet traffic, you can enable the bridge mode option with your wireless gateway to do Comcast Router VPN Setup.

Do note that some routers might not work with a VPN. If you do encounter such an issue, you can try the following troubleshooting steps to install a VPN on a router:

  1. Update your router’s firmware.
  2. Try changing your protocols.
  3. Make sure you’re only using a premium VPN. 
Get a VPN For Xfinity30 Days Money Back Guarantee

How to Prevent Comcast from Secretly Spying on You?

If you don’t know, Comcast is known to collect and sell the browsing data of its users. In fact, through the browsing data associated with your internet traffic, Comcast can determine the websites you visit, products you purchase online, and even the text and emails you send online.

That said, a VPN can help you deal with this issue. Since a VPN can actually encrypt your network traffic, Comcast won’t be able to determine any of your online activities. No matter what you access or share online, Comcast won’t be able to secretly spy on you.

However, instead of looking for the best free VPN for Comcast, we suggest you always use a premium VPN service like ExpressVPN.


FAQs

ExpressVPN works best with Xfinity as it’s quite secure and fast. It offers a variety of advanced security features like a kill switch, DNS leak protection, TrustedServer Technology, and more that ensure your anonymity and safety from Comcast’s data harvesting tactics.

Yes, Comcast Xfinity can see your internet history. It can store your data and sell your information to third-party advertisers. So, in order to stay protected, you need a VPN that can keep you away from Comcast’s prying.

Yes, your Comcast can detect that you’re using a VPN unless you’re using the OpenVPN protocol, which technically hides your traffic from your ISP. However, to stay completely secure, using the best VPN for Comcast Xfinity, like ExpressVPN, is one way to go about it.

Yes, Comcast is infamous for throttling your bandwidth speeds. This means that your speeds can dramatically slow down unless you use a reliable VPN service for Comcast Xfinity like ExpressVPN.

Port forwarding methods differ router by router. To forward ports on your Comcast, you need to check out the instructions for the specific brand of your router. Here are the generic steps you can follow to forward ports on Comcast:

  • Go to xfinity.com/myxFi or use the Xfinity app to log in to your Xfinity account using your ID and password.
  • Click on the “Connect tab”.
  • Click on “See Network” located under the name of your WiFi network.
  • Click on “Advanced Settings” located under “More”.
  • Click on “Port Forwarding” from the available menu.
  • Choose Port Forwarding.
  • Now, using the drop-down list of connected devices, choose the device you want the port forward to be set up for.
    Important: In case you can’t find the device listed, it could be because it’s using an IPv6 address, it is not connected to your home network, or is set up to use a static IP set from the Gateway Admin Page.
  • Next, choose a preset port forwarding configuration for devices like Xbox or PlayStation or you can go for the Manual Setup process and choose specific port numbers, protocols or ranges.
    Important: In case you don’t know which port settings to use, go through the manual of the device or the application you are trying to set up port forwarding for. Also, keep in mind that opening any unnecessary ports can pose security risks.
  • Choose “Apply Changes” to complete the port forwarding setup.

You can use the best free VPN for Comcast, but we suggest you not do that. Free VPNs are packed with slow servers and limited speeds, which do not, in any way, help in bypassing ISP throttling. They are also quite risky as they collect user data and sell it to third-party sites.

So, instead of a free VPN for Xfinity, opt for a reliable paid VPN service. We highly recommend ExpressVPN, all hail to its overall premium service, including fast speeds and robust security.

Yes, you can torrent anonymously on Xfinity with the help of a VPN. A reliable VPN like ExpressVPN would protect you from all the unwanted attention and getting caught. When you conceal your identity from your internet service provider and the government, you can torrent without any worries. And so, a VPN is the best way to keep you anonymous on Xfinity.

Wrapping up!

With net neutrality laws designed to protect user privacy now being shunned by the lobbying of giant corporations like Comcast, Xfinity’s bandwidth throttling and data harvesting are likely going to go away anytime soon.

If you’re tired of glitchy streaming, blocked access to torrent sites, and overall sluggish internet performance, it is high time to invest in an Xfinity VPN. We have mentioned the best VPN for Comcast Xfinity that you can use and have a secure connection.

However, our top choice is ExpressVPN, given its server network, speeds, and advanced security features. This VPN provider further comes with a 3-month free subscription on its annual plan that you can use to enjoy VPN protection for 15 months.